They can help a lot, since older sites often have drawings that no longer match what is in the field after years of modifications. Small changes add up over time, from a bypass added during a shutdown to a pump replaced with a different model or a line rerouted to clear a new structure, and not every change makes it back onto the drawings, especially at sites that predate a formal management of change process or have changed owners several times.
Laser scans or photos from the field show what is actually there, and comparing them to the model highlights where the drawings are wrong. A laser scan captures the geometry of an area in detail, while photos taken by field teams can confirm whether a valve, instrument or connection exists and how it is arranged. Overlaying either on the model makes the differences visible, such as equipment in a different position, a line that does not appear on the drawing or a valve that has been removed.
The practical approach is to use scans to check and correct the areas that matter most, like where work is planned or where drawings are known to be poor, rather than scanning everything at once. A full site scan is expensive and produces far more data than most teams can process, and much of it covers areas that rarely see work. Targeting areas ahead of a turnaround, a major project or frequent maintenance gives the most value for the effort, and operators and maintenance crews usually know which parts of the site have the worst drawings.
Any correction should still go back into the official drawings, so the model and the documents stay consistent. If the model is fixed but the P&ID is not, the next person planning an isolation from the drawing will work from the wrong information, and the next update to the model from that drawing may undo the correction. Corrections should go through the site’s normal drawing control process, which usually means an engineer reviews the difference, updates the drawing and issues a new revision.
Scans also need some interpretation before they are useful, since a point cloud shows surfaces rather than tags, and someone has to confirm which piece of equipment or which line a given shape represents. Field photos tied to equipment tags are often a simpler starting point for confirming connections and valves, with full laser scanning reserved for areas where precise geometry matters, such as planning a heavy lift or fitting new equipment into a tight space.
