Back to Blog
Blog

How can operators suggest a better procedure step without logging a deviation?

How can operators suggest a better procedure step without logging a deviation?

Operators notice when a step is wrong, unclear or out of date long before anyone in the office does, but if the only way to say so is to log a formal…

Operators notice when a step is wrong, unclear or out of date long before anyone in the office does, but if the only way to say so is to log a formal deviation, most of that feedback never gets written down. A suggestion is a different thing from a deviation, since the operator still did the job as written and just thinks the step could be better.

Formal deviation processes exist for good reasons, and they often involve a reason code, a supervisor review and sometimes an investigation, which is far too heavy for a note that a tag number is wrong or that two steps would be easier in the other order. Operators know this, so they mention it in passing to a colleague or not at all, and the same small problem trips up the next crew and the one after that.

Mixing suggestions into the deviation record also distorts it, since the log then fills with entries that are not real departures from the procedure, which makes the real ones harder to spot and the deviation numbers harder to interpret. Anyone reviewing deviation trends needs to trust that each entry represents work that was done differently from the procedure, and a log full of suggestions undermines that trust.

The easiest fix is to let operators leave a comment or suggested change on the exact step, right from the device, which then goes to whoever owns the procedure for review. Because the suggestion is attached to the step, the owner sees exactly which instruction it refers to, which revision was in use and who raised it, so they can follow up with the operator if they need more detail.

That keeps the deviation record clean for real departures from the procedure, and it gives procedure owners a steady flow of improvements from the people who actually do the work. The flow only continues if operators see something happen, so owners should respond to suggestions, accept the good ones into the next revision and explain briefly when a suggestion is not taken up.