With that many requirements, a manual review usually ends up as a quick scan, since nobody can carefully check every item for every vendor. A reviewer facing a hundred or more requirements across a stack of policies, certificates, statistics and procedures will naturally focus on the items they know best or consider most important and skim the rest, especially when several vendors are waiting and other work is piling up.
The result is that some requirements get real attention and others get a tick without much thought. Which requirements get attention can vary from reviewer to reviewer, so two vendors with similar evidence may get different outcomes depending on who reviewed them, and the record of the review rarely shows how each item was judged. That inconsistency is hard to defend if a vendor challenges a decision or if an incident leads to questions about how the vendor was approved.
Scoring works better when each requirement has clear criteria for what counts as acceptable evidence, and the evidence is checked against those criteria one requirement at a time. A requirement that the vendor has a safety management system is hard to score consistently, while one that asks for a documented system covering specified elements, with evidence of an internal audit in the past year, gives every reviewer the same standard. Writing criteria at that level takes effort up front, but it also makes clear to vendors what is expected of them.
AI can do the first pass across all of them and show which ones are met, which are partial and which are missing, so the reviewer can focus their time on the requirements that actually need judgment. For each requirement the first pass should point to the evidence it relied on, such as the page of the policy or the figure in the statistics form, so the reviewer can check the reasoning rather than search for it. Requirements marked as met with clear evidence can then be confirmed quickly, while partial and missing items get the reviewer’s closer attention.
Weighting is worth thinking about as well, since not all requirements carry the same risk, and a vendor missing a fatality prevention requirement is a very different case from one missing a minor administrative item. Many sites group requirements into critical ones that must be met before approval and others that can be met through a corrective action plan, which makes the overall score easier to interpret and keeps the approval decision focused on what matters most.
