Reviewers should always be able to override the AI, and the override should be easy to do and recorded with a reason. The AI might miss context the reviewer has, like a vendor relationship, a known exception or an industry practice, and the reviewer is the one accountable for the decision. If overriding is awkward or discouraged, reviewers tend to either accept findings they disagree with or work around the system entirely, and neither outcome produces good decisions.
The context the AI lacks is often quite ordinary, since a vendor may have submitted an older certificate because the renewal is in progress and the reviewer has confirmed it by phone, or a regional regulator may accept a different form of evidence than the one the criteria describe. In other cases the AI may simply misread a document, such as a poor quality scan or a table it could not interpret, and the reviewer can see what the page actually says.
Recording the reason matters for two reasons, since it creates an audit trail for the decision and it shows where the AI’s assessments are consistently wrong. The audit trail is important because anyone looking at the decision later, whether an auditor, a manager or a colleague handling the renewal, needs to see both what the AI found and why the reviewer decided differently. A short reason in plain words is enough, such as a note that the renewal was confirmed with the broker and a new certificate is due by a given date, and offering a few common categories alongside a free text note makes the reasons easier to analyze later.
If reviewers keep overriding the same type of finding, that is a signal the criteria or the AI need adjusting. A run of overrides on one requirement might mean the criteria are stricter than the site actually applies, that the requirement is worded in a way vendors misunderstand or that the AI is consistently misreading a common document format. Reviewing overrides regularly, monthly or quarterly for example, and fixing the underlying cause reduces the override rate over time and makes the first pass more useful.
Overrides should also work in both directions, since a reviewer should be able to mark a requirement as not met even when the AI found it acceptable, and those cases deserve the same reason and record. Some sites also ask for a second reviewer when an override moves a critical requirement from not met to met, which adds a check on the decisions that carry the most risk without slowing down routine reviews.
