Back to Blog
Blog

What should a good proof of concept test before a live field rollout?

What should a good proof of concept test before a live field rollout?

A good proof of concept tests the parts that are hardest to fix later, which are usually whether the tool handles your real documents and data, whether…

A good proof of concept tests the parts that are hardest to fix later, which are usually whether the tool handles your real documents and data, whether it fits how your crews actually work and whether it meets your security and IT requirements. Testing on clean sample data or a polished demo tells you very little about any of those, since almost every tool looks good when it is shown the documents it was designed around.

Real documents are where most tools first struggle, so the test should include the awkward ones as well as the tidy ones, like scanned procedures with handwritten markups, tables that run across pages, documents with inconsistent numbering and procedures that refer to other procedures. Picking a set that represents the range of the library, rather than the best examples, gives a far more honest picture of how much review and cleanup the full rollout will need.

Fit with the way crews work can only be tested by putting the tool in the hands of the people who will use it, on real jobs or close simulations, in the conditions they normally face, which may mean gloves, poor signal, bright sunlight or a noisy plant room. Watching where people hesitate, what they work around and what they ask for tells you more than any survey, and including a skeptical operator or two in the group usually produces the most useful feedback.

Security and IT requirements belong in the proof of concept rather than after it, since discovering at the end that the tool cannot meet a data residency rule or connect through the company’s identity provider can undo months of good results. Running the security review in parallel, and testing at least one realistic connection to an existing system, avoids that surprise.

It should also have clear success criteria agreed up front, like how accurately procedures are converted, how long tasks take compared with today and whether the people involved would choose to keep using it. Those answers are what make the decision about a field rollout straightforward rather than a matter of opinion, and writing them down before the test starts stops the goalposts from moving once people have formed a view one way or the other.