Back to Blog
Blog

When is shadow mode appropriate for safety critical AI?

When is shadow mode appropriate for safety critical AI?

Shadow mode, where the AI runs alongside the existing process without affecting decisions, makes sense when the cost of a wrong recommendation is high…

Shadow mode, where the AI runs alongside the existing process without affecting decisions, makes sense when the cost of a wrong recommendation is high and you need evidence of how the AI performs before relying on it. It lets you compare the AI’s output with what people actually decided, on real work, without any risk to the job, which is a much stronger test than a demonstration on hand picked examples.

Safety critical uses are where this matters most, such as recommending isolation points, reviewing permits for conflicts or flagging when a job should stop, since a confident error in any of those can put people at risk. In those areas it is hard to justify putting AI into the decision path on the strength of vendor testing alone, and shadow mode gives the site its own evidence from its own work, including the unusual cases that never appear in a demo.

Running it well means recording both the AI’s output and the human decision for each case, then reviewing the differences regularly with people who understand the work. The disagreements are the valuable part, since each one shows either an AI error worth understanding or a case where the AI caught something the people missed, and both kinds should be logged and discussed rather than just counted. The people making the real decisions should not see the AI’s output during this period, otherwise the comparison stops being independent.

It should have a defined end, with clear criteria for moving out of shadow mode, otherwise it can drag on indefinitely. Those criteria are best agreed before the trial starts and might cover how many cases need to be reviewed, what level of agreement is acceptable and which types of error rule out moving forward regardless of the overall rate, since a single serious miss on a critical case may matter more than many correct answers.

Once the results show the AI is reliable for a specific use, it can move to a supporting role where people still make the decision with the AI’s input in front of them. That approval should apply to the specific use that was tested rather than to the AI in general, so a new use or a significant change to the model or its inputs would go back through shadow mode before being trusted in the same way.