A critical control should block progress when skipping it would expose someone to a fatal risk, like proceeding with confined space entry without a gas test or starting work before an isolation is verified. These are the points where a missed step leaves no margin for recovery, since once someone has entered a space with a bad atmosphere or put their hands on equipment that is still energized, nothing later in the procedure can undo the exposure.
In those cases the next step should stay locked until the control is recorded as done, and the recording should capture something meaningful, such as the actual gas readings, the isolation points verified and who verified them, rather than a single checkbox. That way the block cannot be satisfied with a quick tap, and the record shows that the control was actually performed rather than just acknowledged.
Blocking every step is a mistake, though, since operators will find workarounds if the system stops them for things that do not need it. When minor checks are enforced as strictly as critical ones, people learn to enter whatever gets them to the next screen, and that habit carries over to the steps where it really matters, so overusing blocks can end up weakening the controls they were meant to protect.
The best approach is to block only the small number of controls that genuinely prevent fatal outcomes, with a clear and recorded way to escalate when the control truly cannot be done as written. Deciding which controls qualify is best done with the bow tie or critical control register in hand, so the blocking points match the controls the site has already identified as critical, and the list should be reviewed with operators to confirm that each one is practical in the field.
Escalation matters because real conditions do not always match the procedure, such as a gas detector failing on a remote site or an isolation point that has been modified since the procedure was written. The escalation path should name who can authorize an alternative, require the reason and the alternative control to be recorded and be visible to supervisors afterwards, so exceptions are reviewed and recurring ones lead to a change in the procedure rather than becoming routine.
